Website Audit Checklist: 40 Checks and a Free Template

10 min read

On this page
Illustration of a website audit checklist with six sections and 40 checks, above three priority levels from fix now to polish later

A website audit checklist six things: whether Google can crawl and index your pages, how fast and stable the site is, whether the content and on-page SEO match what people search for, whether visitors can convert, whether the site is secure and accessible, and whether tracking works. Run the 40 checks below in that order, because a page that is not indexed cannot rank, however good it is. A small site takes two to four hours with free tools.

We ran this checklist on our own site, echobyteglobal.com, in its first month, and we share what we found, including mistakes. Use the tables as your template: copy them into Google Sheets or Excel and add columns for status, owner and notes.

Key takeaways

  • Audit in order: indexing first, then speed, on-page, user experience, security and accessibility, and tracking.
  • Mark each issue P1 (blocks indexing or breaks pages), P2 (hurts speed or clicks) or P3 (polish), and fix in that order.
  • Free tools cover most of it: Google Search Console, PageSpeed Insights, Screaming Frog and Ahrefs Webmaster Tools.
  • Most serious problems are simple: a stray noindex, a wrong canonical, a broken redirect or a missing sitemap.
  • Audit quarterly, and after any redesign or migration.

What is a website audit?

A website audit is a structured review of how well a site works for search engines and for visitors. An SEO audit focuses on crawling, indexing and rankings. A content audit reviews each page’s quality. A UX audit looks at usability and conversion. This checklist combines all three, since problems in one often cause problems in another. Our SEO audit cost guide explains what paid audits include and cost.

Which free tools do you need?

ToolWhat it checks
Google Search ConsoleIndexing, sitemaps, search performance, Core Web Vitals
Bing Webmaster ToolsBing indexing, which also feeds some AI search tools
PageSpeed InsightsSpeed and Core Web Vitals, lab and real-user data
Screaming Frog SEO Spider (free to 500 URLs)Crawls your site for titles, headings, status codes, links
Ahrefs Webmaster Tools (free for verified sites)Site audit issues and backlinks
Google Analytics 4Whether tracking and conversions work
WAVE or axeAccessibility errors

The website audit checklist: 40 checks

1. Crawling and indexing (10 checks)

These come first. If Google cannot reach or keep a page, nothing else matters. Google’s technical requirements are simple: Googlebot is not blocked, the page returns a 200 status, and it has indexable content.

#CheckHow to checkPass if
1robots.txtOpen /robots.txtImportant pages are not blocked and the sitemap is listed
2XML sitemapSearch Console, Sitemaps reportSubmitted, no errors, lists only live canonical URLs with correct dates
3Indexed pagesSearch Console, Pages reportImportant pages are indexed, and “not indexed” reasons are understood
4No stray noindexURL Inspection and a crawlNo noindex on pages you want to rank
5Canonical tagsCrawl and view sourceEach page points to itself, not to staging or another site
6One site versionTry http, https, www and non-wwwAll redirect with 301 to one https version
7Status codesCrawl200 for live pages, 301 for moved pages, 404 or 410 for removed ones, no soft 404s
8Redirect chains and loopsCrawlOld URLs reach the final page in one hop, never more than three
9Orphan pages and click depthCrawl compared with the sitemapEvery page has internal links, and key pages are within three clicks
10JavaScript renderingURL Inspection, view the tested pageMain text and links appear in the rendered HTML

2. Speed and stability (5 checks)

#CheckHow to checkPass if
11Core Web VitalsPageSpeed Insights, Search ConsoleLCP 2.5 s or less, INP 200 ms or less, CLS 0.1 or less
12ImagesPageSpeed and DevToolsModern formats, correct sizes, lazy-loaded below the fold, main image not lazy-loaded
13FontsDevToolsFew font files, preloaded, text visible while fonts load
14Scripts and third partiesPageSpeed, DevToolsNo large scripts blocking the page, and unused tags removed
15Hosting and cachingDevTools, network tabFast server response, a CDN and sensible caching

Google’s thresholds are measured at the 75th percentile of real visits. See web.dev’s guide to Core Web Vitals.

3. On-page SEO and content (10 checks)

#CheckHow to checkPass if
16Title tagsCrawlUnique per page, about 50 to 60 characters, main topic first
17Meta descriptionsCrawl and search resultsUnique, about 150 characters, readable, not cut off
18HeadingsCrawlOne H1, logical H2 and H3 order with no skipped levels
19Duplicate headingsRead the pageNo two headings with the same text on one page
20Image alt textCrawlDescribes the image, no keyword stuffing
21URLsCrawlShort, lowercase, readable, no parameters on key pages
22Internal linksCrawlDescriptive anchors, and each key page has several links in
23Duplicate and thin contentCrawl, Search ConsoleNo near-identical pages, and thin pages merged or improved
24Search intentSearch your keywordThe page answers the query early and matches what ranks
25Trust signalsRead the pageNamed author, dates, sources, contact details, a real About page

Structured data (Article, Organization, Breadcrumb) is useful when it matches visible content. Check it with Google’s Rich Results Test. It will not fix weak content.

4. User experience and conversion (5 checks)

#CheckHow to checkPass if
26First screenLoad on a phone and a laptopA new visitor can tell what you offer and for whom in seconds
27Main call to actionClick throughVisible, specific and working on every key page
28FormsSubmit a test enquiryWorks, confirms, reaches the right inbox and blocks spam
29NavigationUse the site on a phoneSimple menu, and key pages reachable in one or two taps
30Broken links and 404 pageCrawlNo broken internal links, and a helpful 404 page

5. Security, mobile and accessibility (5 checks)

#CheckHow to checkPass if
31HTTPSBrowser padlock, crawlValid certificate, no mixed content
32Mobile usabilityTest on a real phoneReadable text, tappable buttons, no sideways scrolling
33Color contrastWAVE or axeText meets WCAG AA contrast of 4.5:1, or 3:1 for large text
34Keyboard and screen readersTab through the pageEvery control reachable and labeled, with visible focus
35Privacy and consentCheck cookie banner and policyConsent works, and policies are linked in the footer

6. Tracking and off-site (5 checks)

#CheckHow to checkPass if
36Analytics and conversionsGA4 real-time and reportsKey actions (form, call, purchase) recorded once each
37Search Console and BingCheck ownershipBoth verified, with sitemaps submitted
38Duplicate or missing tagsTag preview, browser extensionEach tag fires once on the right pages
39BacklinksAhrefs Webmaster ToolsNo manual actions, and junk links reviewed rather than panicked over
40Business profilesSearch your brandName, description and links consistent across your profiles

Our analytics service sets up tracking and dashboards if you want help with sections 4 and 6.

What did we find when we audited our own site?

We ran these checks on echobyteglobal.com in its first month and found real problems alongside good news. We share them because most audit guides show hypothetical examples.

What we foundWhy it mattersThe fix
New posts took about two days to appear on the blog indexSlow discovery of new contentRefresh the index and sitemap automatically on publish
Meta descriptions were cut off at about 160 charactersWeaker search snippetsWrite excerpts of 155 characters or less
A blank excerpt produced an auto-generated meta descriptionA random sentence became the snippetAlways set the excerpt by hand
An internal publishing-notes block was visible on a live postLooks careless and confuses readersRemove it, then check every live page after publishing
A post used H3 and H4 where it should have used H2 and H3Broken outline for readers and crawlersFix heading levels (check 18)
Identical headings appeared twice on a page, creating a duplicate anchorConfusing navigation and contents listRename one heading (check 19)
An SEO plugin inserted the keyword into alt text and an introAwkward, stuffed wordingReview automatic edits (checks 20 and 24)
Every “Keep reading” block showed the same three newest postsWasted internal linksShow related posts instead (check 22)
More than 50 junk backlinks from numbered .xyz domains appeared in OctoberLooks alarming but is common spamIgnore, and do not disavow unless Google sends a manual action
A test of a new post found no blockers: it returned 200 to normal visitors and to Googlebot, had no noindex, a self-referencing canonical and a sitemap entryShows the delay was normal new-site discovery, not a faultWait, request indexing and keep publishing quality

The last two rows are the useful lesson. A new domain can look broken in third-party tools while being technically fine. Two weeks in, Ahrefs still showed no organic keywords and a Domain Rating of zero. Check the facts (checks 1 to 10), fix what is broken and be patient with the rest.

How should you prioritize the fixes?

PriorityWhat it coversExamples from the checklistWhen
P1Anything that blocks indexing or breaks pagesChecks 1 to 10, 28, 30, 31This week
P2Problems that hurt speed, snippets or internal linkingChecks 11 to 15, 16 to 22, 36 to 38Within a month
P3Polish and long-term improvementsChecks 23 to 27, 29, 32 to 35, 39, 40Over the quarter

How often should you audit a website?

Run the full checklist every quarter, and run sections 1 and 6 monthly. Run it again after any redesign, replatform or domain change. Our website migration checklist covers the extra steps for moves, and our website redesign cost guide explains how to redesign without losing rankings.

Should you audit your site yourself or hire help?

Your situationBest approach
A small site with under about 50 pagesDIY with this checklist and free tools
A site that depends on search for leads or salesA paid audit, then fixes with a developer
An online store with thousands of URLsA specialist with a crawler and server-log access
A site that dropped in traffic and you don’t know whyA specialist audit, starting with sections 1 and 2
A redesign, replatform or domain change is plannedAn audit before the move, plus the migration checklist

Paid audits typically cost $500 to $5,000 for small and mid-size sites, according to our SEO audit cost guide. Our SEO pricing guide covers ongoing support after the audit.

How do we audit sites at Echobyte?

Our SEO service starts from $600 a month and includes a technical audit, with no ranking guarantee. When we redesign an existing site through our web development service, we audit it, keep what works and set up redirects so you don’t lose search rankings. We use the same checks on every project, including our own site, and we work through the fixes in priority order. Our headless WordPress guide explains how publishing and caching work on the Next.js setup we use. See our pricing page for starting prices.

Website audit checklist FAQ

What should a website audit include?

At minimum: crawling and indexing, speed and Core Web Vitals, on-page SEO and content, user experience and conversion, security and accessibility, and tracking. The 40 checks above cover all six.

How do I audit my website for free?

Use Google Search Console, PageSpeed Insights, Screaming Frog’s free version (up to 500 URLs), Ahrefs Webmaster Tools and your browser’s developer tools. Work through the checklist in order.

How long does a website audit take?

About two to four hours for a small site. Larger sites and online stores take longer, mostly because of crawl size.

How often should I audit my website?

Every quarter for a full audit, monthly for indexing and tracking, and after any redesign, migration or traffic drop.

What is the difference between a website audit and an SEO audit?

An SEO audit focuses on search visibility: crawling, indexing, on-page SEO and links. A website audit adds user experience, security, accessibility and tracking.

What are the most common website audit problems?

Pages blocked by noindex or robots.txt, wrong canonicals, redirect chains, missing or duplicate titles and descriptions, skipped heading levels, slow images and broken tracking.

How much does a website audit cost?

Free if you do it yourself. Paid audits for small and mid-size sites typically cost $500 to $5,000, and enterprise audits cost more.

Should I disavow spam backlinks?

Usually not. Unless Google has sent you a manual action, junk links from spam domains are best ignored.

Want an expert to run these checks and fix what they find? Our team audits your site, ranks the issues and fixes them in priority order, and every project starts with a free discovery call and a fixed quote.

Sources

Need help with this for your business?